Davids Premium Natural Toothpaste, Spearmint (Fluoride Free, 5.25 oz)
Analysis updated September 2026 · How Scout scores
At a glance
Summary
This toothpaste features a clean formula with beneficial ingredients such as xylitol and baking soda, which are known for their cavity-reducing and gentle abrasive properties. The absence of harmful chemicals like fluoride, SLS, and artificial sweeteners contributes to its high rating. Additionally, the use of natural mint oils enhances its antimicrobial properties and freshens breath without the use of synthetic additives.
Key ingredients 14
Xylitol (Birch Derived)Very Good
Xylitol is a natural sweetener that has been shown to reduce cavity-causing bacteria in the mouth. It helps maintain oral health by inhibiting the growth of harmful bacteria. This makes it a highly beneficial ingredient in oral care products.
Risks
Excessive consumption can cause digestive upset, but this is not a concern in toothpaste.
Benefits
Reduces cavity-causing bacteria and promotes oral health.
Vegetable GlycerinGood
Beneficial ingredient — whole-food or functional value in this product class.
Benefits
Helps maintain moisture in the toothpaste, ensuring a smooth texture.
Sodium Bicarbonate (Baking Soda)Good
Sodium bicarbonate acts as a gentle abrasive and neutralizes acids in the mouth, which can help prevent tooth decay. It is well-regarded for its ability to clean teeth without being overly abrasive. Additionally, it can help whiten teeth by removing surface stains.
Risks
Overuse can lead to enamel wear, but it is generally safe in toothpaste formulations.
Benefits
Neutralizes acids and acts as a gentle abrasive to clean teeth.
Mentha Piperita (Peppermint) OilGood
Peppermint oil is used for its natural antimicrobial properties and ability to freshen breath. It is a popular ingredient in oral care products for its pleasant flavor and potential to reduce oral bacteria.
Risks
May cause irritation in sensitive individuals, but generally safe in toothpaste.
Benefits
Provides antimicrobial benefits and freshens breath.
Mentha Gracilis (Scotch Spearmint) OilGood
Scotch spearmint oil is valued for its natural antimicrobial properties and refreshing flavor. It helps to freshen breath and may reduce oral bacteria, making it beneficial in oral care products.
Risks
May cause irritation in sensitive individuals, but generally safe in toothpaste.
Benefits
Offers antimicrobial benefits and a refreshing flavor.
Mentha Spicata Herb (Spearmint) OilGood
Spearmint oil is used for its antimicrobial properties and ability to freshen breath. It is a common ingredient in oral care products for its pleasant taste and potential to reduce oral bacteria.
Risks
May cause irritation in sensitive individuals, but generally safe in toothpaste.
Benefits
Provides antimicrobial benefits and freshens breath.
Calcium Carbonate (Limestone Micro Abrasives)Neutral
Calcium carbonate is used as a mild abrasive in toothpaste to help remove plaque and surface stains. It is generally considered safe and effective for this purpose. However, it does not provide any additional antimicrobial or remineralizing benefits.
Risks
Excessive use of abrasives can potentially wear down enamel over time.
Benefits
Helps in cleaning teeth by removing plaque and surface stains.
Purified WaterNeutral
Purified water is used as a solvent in toothpaste formulations. It is essential for dissolving other ingredients and ensuring the product's consistency. It does not have direct oral health benefits.
Risks
No risks are associated with purified water in toothpaste.
Benefits
Ensures the proper consistency and solubility of the toothpaste.
Hydrated SilicaNeutral
Hydrated silica is used as an abrasive to help clean teeth and remove plaque. It is generally considered safe and effective for this purpose. However, it does not provide additional antimicrobial or remineralizing benefits.
Risks
Can be abrasive if used excessively, potentially leading to enamel wear.
Benefits
Helps clean teeth by removing plaque and surface stains.
Sodium Cocoyl GlutamateNeutral
Sodium cocoyl glutamate is a mild surfactant derived from coconut oil and glutamic acid. It helps to create foam and improve the texture of toothpaste. It is considered safe and non-irritating.
Benefits
Provides mild cleansing and foaming action in toothpaste.
Illicium Verum (Anise) Fruit OilNeutral
Anise fruit oil is used for its flavoring properties in toothpaste. It provides a unique taste and is generally considered safe for use in oral care products. However, it does not have significant oral health benefits.
Risks
May cause allergic reactions in sensitive individuals.
Benefits
Adds a unique flavor to the toothpaste.
Citrus Aurantium Amara (Orange) Peel OilNeutral
Orange peel oil is used for its flavoring properties and potential antimicrobial effects. It is generally considered safe for use in oral care products. However, its oral health benefits are not well-documented.
Risks
May cause irritation in sensitive individuals.
Benefits
Provides a pleasant citrus flavor and potential antimicrobial effects.
Stevia (Leaf Extract)Neutral
Stevia is a natural sweetener used to enhance the flavor of toothpaste without adding sugar. It is considered safe and non-cariogenic, meaning it does not contribute to tooth decay. However, it does not provide additional oral health benefits.
Benefits
Sweetens toothpaste without contributing to tooth decay.
Carrageenan (Seaweed Derived)Bad
Processed additive flagged under Scout's ingredient doctrine.
Risks
Some concerns exist about its inflammatory potential in the digestive system, but this is not relevant for toothpaste.
Benefits
Improves the texture and stability of the toothpaste.
Processing
Processed Culinary Ingredients
Get the full breakdown in the Scout appTake Scout shopping
Scan any product to see lab results, healthy alternatives, and your personalized analysis.
Download on theApp Store GET IT ONGoogle PlayAmazon pricing & content
Amazon price as of . Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.
CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED “AS IS” AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME.