7 products in Scout's rankings · Updated October 2026 · How we score
Scout has scored 7 Straus Family Creamery products in its rankings. Scores run from 40 to 95 out of 100: 2 rate Excellent, 4 Good and 1 Poor. The highest is Straus Family Creamery Organic Cream-Top Whole Milk at 95/100 (#19 of 53 in Milk); the lowest is Straus Family Creamery Cookie Dough at 40/100. One is a Scout's Pick (scored 88+).
At a glance
Straus Family Creamery products, by Scout score
Ordered by Scout score. Each score compares a product with others in its own category; the line under each one says where it places there.
Straus Family Creamery products by category
| Category | Products | Scores | Best rank |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ice Cream | 4 | 40–85 | #5 of 47 |
| Kefir | 2 | 81–83 | #13 of 17 |
| Milk | 1 | 95 | #19 of 53 |
Ingredients Scout flags across Straus Family Creamery
Ingredients rated harmful in Scout's analyses that appear in at least two of these 7 products. Each link opens Scout's analysis of the ingredient.
- Organic cane sugar in 4 of 7
Beneficial ingredients across Straus Family Creamery
Ingredients rated beneficial in Scout's analyses that appear in at least two of these 7 products.
- Organic egg yolks in 4 of 7
- Organic vanilla extract in 4 of 7
- Organic cream & nonfat milk in 3 of 7
- Pasteurized low fat milk in 2 of 7
- Sweet cream buttermilk in 2 of 7
- Live and active probiotic cultures in 2 of 7
Common questions about Straus Family Creamery
What is the highest-scoring Straus Family Creamery product?
Straus Family Creamery Organic Cream-Top Whole Milk, at 95/100 — #19 of 53 in Milk.
What is the lowest-scoring Straus Family Creamery product?
Straus Family Creamery Cookie Dough, at 40/100 — #37 of 47 in Ice Cream. Its product page lists the ingredients behind the score.
How does Scout score Straus Family Creamery products?
Each product gets its own 1–100 score, judged against other products in the same category with a category-specific framework: the full ingredient list, plus the published processing level, the packaging and any credible lab results where they apply. Scout does not score brands, and no brand pays for a score or a position.