Smart Sweets Caramels
Summary
Smart Sweets Caramels score 35/100. Third-party 2025 testing detected 240 ppb arsenic — unexpected given the brand's 'healthier' positioning. The ingredient panel is genuinely cleaner than any mass-market candy on this list: real butter, heavy cream, allulose, stevia, and no petroleum dyes or artificial flavors. The arsenic reading substantially undermines the 'clean label' promise, and chicory root fiber can cause GI distress in sensitive individuals. Nova 4 still applies due to the allulose + fiber syrup matrix. Owned by Smart Sweets / Tiny Miracles Confectionery.
At a glance
Contaminants 1
Source: Independent third-party laboratory testing
Arsenic 240 ppb High
Detected at a high level — at or above health-based exposure limits. Regular exposure at this level is a genuine health concern. No safe level of arsenic exposure exists; chronic exposure is linked to increased cancer risk (lung, skin, kidney, bladder), cardiovascular disease, and neurodevelopmental harm in children.
Independent third-party testing detected arsenic at 240 parts per billion — a notable contamination level.
Key ingredients 12
Chicory Root Fiber (Inulin)Neutral
Prebiotic fiber; can cause GI distress (bloating, gas, diarrhea) at typical candy serving sizes in sensitive individuals.
See more about Chicory Root Fiber (Inulin) →AlluloseGood
Rare sugar with ~70% sweetness and ~10% calories of sucrose. Minimal blood sugar impact; FDA-exempted from added-sugar labeling.
See more about Allulose →Butter (Cream, Salt)Good
Real dairy fat — fat-soluble vitamins A, D, E, K; butyrate. Genuine whole-food ingredient.
See more about Butter (Cream, Salt) →Heavy CreamGood
Whole-food dairy fat.
See more about Heavy Cream →Tapioca SyrupNeutral
Moderate-processing sweetener from cassava; higher glycemic than table sugar but used in smaller amounts here.
See more about Tapioca Syrup →Coconut OilGood
Whole-food saturated fat with medium-chain triglycerides.
See more about Coconut Oil →Whey Protein IsolateGood
Bioavailable complete protein.
See more about Whey Protein Isolate →Soluble Corn FiberNeutral
Processed prebiotic fiber.
See more about Soluble Corn Fiber →SaltNeutral
Sodium.
See more about Salt →Sunflower LecithinBad
Sunflower-derived emulsifier — cleaner than soy lecithin but still a refined, processed additive. Scout classifies lecithin emulsifiers as bad.
See more about Sunflower Lecithin →Steviol Glycosides (from Stevia Leaf)Neutral
Natural zero-calorie sweetener from the stevia leaf. No significant health concerns, but Scout treats all stevia forms as neutral — neither penalized nor counted as a beneficial ingredient.
See more about Steviol Glycosides (from Stevia Leaf) →Natural FlavorNeutral
Proprietary but not artificial; more transparent than artificial flavor.
See more about Natural Flavor →Processing
Ultra-Processed Foods
Get the full breakdown in the Scout app
Scan any product to see lab results, healthy alternatives, and your personalized analysis.
Download on theApp Store