Mayfield Ice Cream

Common questions

Is Mayfield Ice Cream healthy?

Mayfield Ice Cream scores 65/100 on Scout's independent analysis of ingredients, additives, and lab results — a fair-to-good score — solid, with tradeoffs. This ice cream contains high-quality ingredients like cream, buttermilk, and natural vanilla, which contribute positively to its nutritional profile.

How processed is Mayfield Ice Cream?

Mayfield Ice Cream is NOVA Group 3: Processed Foods.

Which ingredients drive Mayfield Ice Cream's score?

In Scout's ingredient-by-ingredient analysis, Cream, Buttermilk, Vanilla extract count in its favor; Sugar, Corn syrup are flagged as ingredients of concern. The full breakdown, with why each one matters, is in the Key ingredients section on this page.

You might also like

See more

Mayfield Ice Cream

Mayfield
Bioengineered
65 Fair

Analysis updated August 2026 · How Scout scores

View on Amazon

At a glance

Beneficial ingredients 4
Harmful ingredients 2
Owned by Dairy Farmers of America
Category Ice Cream
Summary

This ice cream contains high-quality ingredients like cream, buttermilk, and natural vanilla, which contribute positively to its nutritional profile. However, the presence of refined sugar and corn syrup, both of which are high-calorie sweeteners with no nutritional benefits, detracts from its healthiness. Additionally, the use of plant-based gums and the level of processing involved in making the ice cream further impact its overall score.

Key ingredients 10

Cream
Good

Cream is a high-quality source of dairy fat, providing essential fatty acids and fat-soluble vitamins. It is minimally processed and contributes to the creamy texture of ice cream. Grass-fed cream would be even more beneficial due to higher omega-3 content.

Risks

High in saturated fats, which may contribute to heart disease if consumed in excess.

Benefits

Provides a rich source of energy and essential fat-soluble vitamins like A, D, E, and K.

See more about Cream →
Buttermilk
Good

Buttermilk is a cultured dairy product that contains probiotics beneficial for gut health. It is low in fat and adds a tangy flavor to the ice cream. The fermentation process enhances its digestibility and nutrient absorption.

Risks

May cause digestive issues for those with lactose intolerance.

Benefits

Contains probiotics that support digestive health and may improve lactose digestion.

See more about Buttermilk →
Vanilla extract
Good

Vanilla extract is a natural flavoring derived from vanilla beans, providing a rich aroma and taste. It contains antioxidants that may have health benefits. Pure vanilla extract is preferable to artificial vanilla flavoring.

Benefits

Contains antioxidants and enhances the flavor profile of foods.

See more about Vanilla extract →
Ground vanilla bean
Good

Ground vanilla bean is a natural flavoring that provides a rich and authentic vanilla taste. It contains antioxidants and is less processed than vanilla extract. The use of whole beans ensures a more complex flavor profile.

Benefits

Rich in antioxidants and provides a natural, complex vanilla flavor.

Whey
Neutral

Liquid whey as a minor dairy ingredient — benign.

Risks

May cause allergic reactions in individuals with dairy allergies.

Benefits

Rich in essential amino acids, supporting muscle growth and repair.

See more about Whey →
Skim milk
Neutral

Standard formulation ingredient — neither beneficial nor harmful at typical use.

Risks

May cause digestive issues for those with lactose intolerance.

Benefits

Rich in calcium and protein, supporting bone health and muscle maintenance.

See more about Skim milk →
Plant based gums (guar, tara)
Neutral

Plant-based gums like guar and tara are used as thickeners and stabilizers in food products. They are derived from natural sources and help improve texture and shelf-life. These gums are generally considered safe and are minimally processed.

Risks

Excessive consumption may cause digestive discomfort in sensitive individuals.

Benefits

Improve texture and stability of food products without significant health risks.

Annatto (color)
Neutral

Annatto is a natural coloring agent derived from the seeds of the achiote tree. It is used to impart a yellow or orange color to foods. Annatto is minimally processed and considered safe for consumption.

Risks

May cause allergic reactions in sensitive individuals.

Benefits

Provides natural color without synthetic additives.

See more about Annatto (color) →
Sugar
Bad

Refined sugar is a high-calorie sweetener with no nutritional benefits. It can contribute to weight gain and metabolic disorders when consumed in excess. Unlike natural sweeteners, it lacks vitamins and minerals.

Risks

Excessive consumption can lead to obesity, type 2 diabetes, and dental cavities.

See more about Sugar →
Corn syrup
Bad

Refined sugar syrup.

Risks

May contribute to increased calorie intake and weight gain if consumed in large amounts.

Benefits

Provides a smooth texture and prevents crystallization in frozen desserts.

See more about Corn syrup →

Processing

Group 3 · Processed

Processed Foods

Get the full breakdown in the Scout appTake Scout shopping

Scan any product to see lab results, healthy alternatives, and your personalized analysis.

Download on theApp Store GET IT ONGoogle Play

More in Ice Cream