Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Image: Open Food Facts (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Common questions

Is Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese healthy?

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese scores 60/100 on Scout's independent analysis of ingredients, additives, and lab results — a fair-to-good score — solid, with tradeoffs. This extra sharp cheddar cheese is made with traditional ingredients like pasteurized milk, cheese cultures, salt, and enzymes, which are typical for cheese production.

How processed is Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese?

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese is NOVA Group 4: Ultra-Processed Foods.

Which ingredients drive Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese's score?

In Scout's ingredient-by-ingredient analysis, Cheese cultures counts in its favor; Natamycin is flagged as an ingredient of concern. The full breakdown, with why each one matters, is in the Key ingredients section on this page.

You might also like

See more

Extra Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Hoffman's
60 Fair

Analysis updated September 2026 · How Scout scores

View on Amazon

At a glance

Beneficial ingredients 1
Harmful ingredients 1
Owned by Hoffmann Family of Companies
Category Cheese
Summary

This extra sharp cheddar cheese is made with traditional ingredients like pasteurized milk, cheese cultures, salt, and enzymes, which are typical for cheese production. However, the inclusion of natamycin as a mold inhibitor and its classification as ultra-processed limit its score. Despite having a clean ingredient list, the processing level imposes a cap on its rating.

Key ingredients 6

Cheese cultures
Good

Cheese cultures are beneficial bacteria used in the fermentation process of cheese. They enhance flavor and texture while contributing to the development of probiotics. These cultures are essential for traditional cheese-making and can support gut health.

Benefits

May support digestive health by promoting a healthy gut microbiome through probiotic activity.

See more about Cheese cultures →
Pasteurized milk
Neutral

Pasteurized milk is a primary ingredient in cheese, providing essential proteins and fats. The pasteurization process kills harmful bacteria but may reduce some beneficial enzymes. It is a standard ingredient in cheese production, offering a balanced nutritional profile.

Benefits

Provides essential nutrients such as calcium and protein, which are beneficial for bone health and muscle maintenance.

See more about Pasteurized milk →
Salt
Neutral

Salt is used in cheese for flavor enhancement and preservation. It is a common ingredient in cheese-making, providing necessary taste and acting as a preservative. While essential in moderation, excessive salt intake can lead to health issues.

Risks

Excessive consumption of salt can lead to high blood pressure and cardiovascular issues.

Benefits

Enhances flavor and acts as a preservative, extending the shelf life of the cheese.

See more about Salt →
Enzymes
Neutral

Enzymes are used in cheese-making to coagulate milk, forming curds and whey. They are crucial for the texture and maturation of cheese. Typically derived from animal or microbial sources, they are standard in cheese production.

Benefits

Essential for the cheese-making process, contributing to the development of texture and flavor.

See more about Enzymes →
Annatto
Neutral

Annatto is a natural colorant derived from the seeds of the achiote tree. It is used to impart a yellow-orange hue to cheese without affecting flavor. As a natural additive, it is generally considered safe.

Risks

Some individuals may experience allergic reactions to annatto.

Benefits

Provides natural coloring to cheese, enhancing visual appeal without synthetic additives.

See more about Annatto →
Natamycin
Bad

Natamycin is a natural mold inhibitor used to prevent spoilage in cheese. While effective in extending shelf life, its use as a preservative raises concerns about potential impacts on gut flora. It is a common additive in cheese but may not be necessary in all cases.

Risks

May disrupt gut microbiota balance if consumed in large quantities over time.

Benefits

Prevents mold growth, extending the shelf life of cheese and reducing food waste.

See more about Natamycin →

Processing

Group 4 · Ultra-processed

Ultra-Processed Foods

Get the full breakdown in the Scout appTake Scout shopping

Scan any product to see lab results, healthy alternatives, and your personalized analysis.

Download on theApp Store GET IT ONGoogle Play

More in Cheese